Loved our Thanksgiving in Catalina! The location was very convenient for ferry arrival and departure and for most of our activities - dining, golf cart rental, mini-golf, and an escape room. It was a longer walk or bus ride to ziplining and hiking trails. A little noisy (lots of cart traffic on the street) for sitting on the outside patio, but not when inside. Well-stocked kitchen, comfortable furnishings, and a pleasing aesthetic. Awkward feature: the pocket door from the master bedroom into the en suite bathroom does not close (bolted in open position), which reduced privacy and also let a lot of light into the sleeping area in the morning. We had some trouble with the living room TV and didn't get a response from the property manager when we texted about it, but just used the 2 other TVs in the bedrooms. Overall, I recommend this rental - will be perfect if they repair the pocket door!