We stayed in #1; and overall, were very happy with our stay; there were a few minor issues you can chalk up to "growing pains", as they were still in "opening" mode... the internet was out for the first day and a half, no toiletries (shampoo, etc) in the bathroom, one coffee pod in the kitchen, and there was still work going on, re-surfacing the driveway...BUT...all those issues were resolved quickly; Ryan was very responsive to our requests, and it's a comfortable, homey cabin, with a kitchen that was easy to work in, plenty of kitchenware (pots/pans, settings for 4), a real stove, roomy fridge, a nice living room area (with ample space for visiting family) and a separate, private bedroom. Close enough to everything we needed, but set back from the street, so you could still hear Fountain Creek. So much better than a motel room, and we will definitely be staying there again next time we're in town. If you're looking for an alternative to the usual motel room, you'd be making a huge mistake if you didn't give The Timber Lodge a try.