Actual overall rating is somewhere between "good" and "excellent". The space is conducive to comfortable family time/activities, combined with the option for more private, quiet surroundings. We suggest simply adding the extra amenities (chairs, bicycles, coolers) into the upfront fee. While the bedrooms are spacious and numerous, the beds are all quite soft -- they could use an upgrade.Kitchen is well equipped, however we did buy a salad spinner. More platters and big bowls would be helpful.Given that the house was ready and vacant prior to the official check-in time, we would have appreciated getting in sooner. Location was perfect, and the beaches are pristine, extending as far as the eye can see! The St. Augustine area is low-key, more charming than much of Florida and fun to explore. Jamie was responsive to our requests.