Private room was a deal at $26. Super-silent (well, for a hostel), and about a 10 minute, very scenic walk to the center.
Much help from the excellent English-speaking staff. Above average breakfast. For $2, you can get a hot meal add on.
The low traffic, lovely street it's on has a decent Italian restaurant and a well-reviewed coffee bar. Also a very large crafts market is moments away.
The nearby Guadaloupe neighborhood is worth a look, sort of the Williamsburg of San Miguel.
Clean, simple rooms. We appreciated that they were pet friendly. Excellent and helpful staff. The property did seem quite noisy in the morning, but we were trying to sleep late. If you are an early riser there should be no problems.
Very friendly staff. The rooms were clean. Location is awesome, far enough from the church that you don't hear the constant ringing, yet only minutes away!!! The only negative I would say is the water pressure in the shower, at times it is very inconsistent.