We visited St. John and stayed at Riley's Retreat for my 40th birthday celebration - I can't say enough wonderful things about both! If you've never been to St. John, go now! It's such a peaceful and laid back place, much less touristy than any island in the Caribbean I've been to before.
The villa is amazing with stunning views and plenty of space for all 12 of us to relax and unwind. Loved all the unique touches, pool, hot tub, outdoor shower and all of the amenities you could possibly need. It really felt like home for a few days. The villa is in a very convenient location, a quick ride away from the Cruz Bay ferry and "downtown" area, but you'll feel like you're miles away when gazing out over the water from the villa's beautiful deck. Dorothy was a fantastic host, always very responsive and provided some great recommendations. The on-island property manager was also super helpful. I have no complaints other than we wish we had stayed longer! Will definitely be back and would definitely recommend Dorothy and Brian's place for a large group.