We rented this home for a week with 4 adults (wife & I + grandparents) and our 2 kids (age 3 and 5). We thoroughly enjoyed our trip!
Positives: the home was as described and seemed even larger than what we were expecting. Layout allows for privacy when needed and also lots of communal spaces. Kitchen was large and had all essential cooking utensils, cutlery, and tableware. The deck, pool and outdoor area are fantastic for hanging out morning, daytime, or evening and having the dock and waterway in the back provided lots of fun for our kids as we tried to catch little fish with a net or look for sea life and birds. (FYI: we bought a little net which we left on-site - I hope whoever comes next will enjoy that too!)
We enjoyed kayaking and paddle boarding in the waterways in the island. Directly across the street from the house is Lazy Turtle Beach Rentals, where the owner, Joe, was really enjoyable and friendly, and got us set up with all gear.
The Donut Experiment, just a couple minute walk away, was fun for the kids and we went everyday once we found it!
An idea: as no spices/condiments are provided (which we knew and understand), it might be nice to provide a starter-pack of small portions of some essentials like salt, pepper, ketchup, butter, etc. As otherwise I imagine everybody who stays for a week buys new and ends up wasting or having to cart home whatever is left over. Just an idea to make this home an even more top-notch stay for everybody!