From beginning to end, our stay at The Atlantic was incomparable! The staff was friendly and accommodating. Rooms and grounds were maintained beautifully and the view was spectacular!
We had a lovely two night stay. The room, the 5 oâclock cocktails at the cozy bar and a wonderful meal on our first night was much appreciated. Iâve been going to Block Island for many years and this first stay at the Atlantic Inn was great. A short walk to town and to Water Street, although a fairly steep hill between, was fun and not too bad.
The price does not match what you expect. For 600+ a night, you would think a TV in the room, complimentary waters (like most hotels do), or towels that fit an adult body would have the bare minimum of service. There is a resort fee which I am not sure what that applies for since they donât offer much.
I would not return nor recommend this hotel to others. I actually told friends of mine that they should look at any other place because I donât think itâs worth the cost.
Really enjoyed our first trip to Block Island and staying at the Atlantic Inn! We had a 2nd floor room with an ocean view and king size bed.
PROS: staff was super sweet; check in and check out easy and accommodating- rose on check in; restaurant for dinner lovely, drinks on porch and lawn lovely; location was close enough to town to walk but far enough to be quiet (the hill HARD on the bike tho haha).
CONS: room had tiny bath and window that would not stay open- shower the size of a phone booth & no closet; breakfast was a waste of money- better to walk to town; no designated entry; could have offered bikes for rent; was our 1 year anniversary and even though i mentioned it to the reception staff and dining staff- no one did anything special- not even a note in the room- sort of a let down.
Lovely relaxing stay at a classic BI hotel. Really enjoyed the on-site dining for dinner, sunset views, and the ability to walk into town or the beach. Would stay again.