Their check-in requirement only lasts 2 hours. Because I couldn't check-in between 3:00 PM and 5:00 PM the staff put a lock box on the door to my room. However, the combination didn't work so I was locked out. I called there off-hours phone line 7 times going up to midnight. I never received a call back so I ended up sleeping in my car. It has been 7 days since I was locked out and I still haven't received a response from them.
The room was incredibly clean. Well appointed for my purpose. Only item of note to light sleepers is that it is fairly close to the train tracks that run through Circleville. As a result between midnight and 7 a.m., it felt like there was a train that went through every 2 hours. Of course when they go through town not only do they just go through town but they sound their whistles so sleep is pretty broken up unless you're a very sound sleeper or have noise cancelling headphones.