As my title states, this should be a 5 star slam dunk. Great house, well decorated, clean, walking distance to town, anything the average person would want in a short term rental; but we had some problems.
We arrived a little around 730p. It was snowing and 25°. The house was cold. We jacked up the heat, ate dinner, used our sleeping bags, watched tv and went to bed. The next day, due to the snow we hung with some friends and touristed. We got back at 530p. It was 35° outside. It was 59° in the house. We realized there was something wrong with the heating. That night I messaged the property manager. They got back to me that night and said it would be fixed. After a trip to sedona the next day we came back and it was fixed. Over the next couple of days we would have to fight with the heating system. It would eventually get to temp, but it took constant minding and resetting the thermostat. They were responsive and nice but the whole thing dings you a point. The reason I say 3 out of four stars, is because of the hot water. You should be able to get 3+ reasonable showers out of a place that has a 4 person occupancy. My wife would take a brief shower and then I had to wait 15 minutes for the water to warm up or wait and hour later to shower. I originally thought it was the furnace thing; but after it was fixed I had two other shower issues.
So as i originally posted. The place should be amazing, but heat and hot water were problematic.