We stayed at She's Always Right after seeing it recommended multiple times on local FB pages. We had been to AMI the year prior, but stayed in Bradenton. We decided for our return trip, location was important! We scoured the maps and looked at several properties. She's Always Right checked every box on the list. There are 3 king bedrooms all with on suite bathrooms, which was perfect for multiple families. The room with twin beds had a bathroom next door and the kids (ages 9, 7, 4) were thrilled about the triple bunk. Additionally, each room had a TV. The communication with the owners was coordinated through email and straightforward check-in and check-out instructions were communicated to us. The house was clean and the backyard space was perfect. There was ample shade on the patio, and spots to sit near the pool. The pool was visible from the living room and the sliding doors were equipped with alarms for safety of swimming children. There were plenty of chairs and pool toys we took with us to the beach as well. The location is ideal, walkable to The Feast and Anna Maria Island Coffee Shack, which were two of our favorites. Lots of cute shopping as well. Quick golf cart ride away from both Bridge Street for shopping and dinner or Pine Street for ice cream (Two Scoops and Dips) and donuts from The Donut Experiment. The home is clean and beautiful, but if any doubts, the 5 minute walk to the beach solidifies how much of a gem this house is. We were easily able to head back and forth each day! Our only real issue was we had some difficulty with the dishwasher draining the first day, but I texted the owners and maintenance was out and promptly fixed it for us. They were also very accommodating to allow us a late checkout. My ONLY (and I mean ONLY) con is that the upstairs bedrooms did not cool as well as the lower. It was a little toasty up there at night when temps were very warm during the day. We grabbed an extra box fan and that helped a little. Would highly recommend this property for anyone looking and if we return to AMI, will look to book here first!
Thank you so much for your thoughtful and detailed review! We're so glad She's Always Right checked all the boxes for your group and that the home's layout, amenities, and location made your return trip to AMI so special. We love hearing that the kids enjoyed the triple bunk and that you were able to take advantage of nearby favorites like The Feast and The Donut Experiment!
We truly appreciate you bringing the note about the upstairs temperature to our attention—feedback like this helps us continue to improve the guest experience. We're also happy to hear that the dishwasher issue was promptly resolved and that the late checkout was helpful for your departure day.
It means the world to us that you'd recommend the home and consider staying with us again—we'd be honored to welcome you back anytime!