My true rating for this property is 4.5. The property is great, location is top notch, space was really good for 4 people, beds were very comfy (and we loved the recliners), and we definitely got use of the hot tub and the fireplace. Overall no complaints with the space.
The only reason I want to deduct .5 a star is because honestly the management/owners didn't supply any cleaning sponges so it was difficult to clean the pans, and there were also no extra paper towels except for the little left on the roll. Also be aware that unlike every other short term rental I've ever stayed in, they seem to clear out all the oils/spices/foil that other guests normally leave behind so you need to make sure to bring all that yourself. And if you're used to a higher standard of cooking stuff, make sure you bring your own!